You May Like
TY Beanie Baby - MATTIE the Cat 7"...NEW with Mint Tags
$16.50
View Details
Ty Beanie Baby Mattie the Cat Excellent Condition with Tag Protector
$16.50
View Details
TY MATTIE the ORANGE TABBY CAT BEANIE BABY - MINT with MINT TAG
$17.95
View Details
TY Beanie Babies - Mattie - Tabby Cat (6.5") Error Tag Ear(2001) Tush (2002) *L8
$18.00
View Details
TY Beanie Baby - MATTIE the Cat (7 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
$19.89
View Details
TY Beanie Baby - MATTIE the Cat Kitten Tabby With Tag
$14.98
View Details
Beanie Babies Collection Mattie w/Tag - Dress Outfit Vintage Collector DOB 2001
$12.95
View Details
Ty Beanie Baby Snip, Prance, Scat, Pounce, Mattie retired 1996 1997 LOT (5) NEW
$79.96
View Details
Beanie Babies Mattie Tabby Cat Retired 2002 Mint
$24.99
View Details
Ty Beanie Baby “Mattie” the Orange Tabby Cat (7 inch)
$24.93
View Details
TY BEANIE BUDDY "MATTIE" the Cat Plush Bean Bag MWMT Style #09481
$39.99
View Details
Ty Beanie Baby Retired "Mattie" the Cat 2001 / 2002 Mismatched Tags Display Box
$19.99
View Details
Ty Beanie Baby - MATTIE the Tabby Cat 7" NEW MWMTs - Stuffed Animal Plush Toy
$12.99
View Details
Ty Beanie Baby Lot of 3-Mattie 2001, Crunch 2018, Oakie 2022 S
$10.00
View Details
Set of 3 Ty Beanie Baby Cats - Beani, Booties, & Mattie
$23.99
View Details
Lot of 4 Ty Cat Beanie Babies Muff Frisco Booties Mattie
$39.97
View Details
Ty Beanie Baby Mattie Cat ~ April 26, 2001 ~ Brown Cat Plush
$19.96
View Details
2001 2002 Ty Beanie Baby MATTIE the Tabby Cat 7 Inch w/ Both Tags No Red Stamp
$12.00
View Details
Mattie 2002 - Ty Beanie Baby SEE VIDEO C
$40.00
View Details
Mattie 2002 - Ty Beanie Baby SEE VIDEO B
$40.00
View Details
A1 Ty Beanie Babies Cats Mattie Tabs Cappuccino Plush 6" Stuffed Toy Lovey
$39.88
View Details
Ty Beanie Babies “Mattie” the Ginger Tabby Cat 2001
$14.99
View Details
Ty Mattie the House Cat Beanie Baby, Mint Condition
$20.80
View Details
6 Cat Beanie Babies (Canyon, Mattie, Chip, Pounce, Stripes, Nip)
$25.00
View Details
Ty Beanie Babies “Mattie” the Ginger Tabby Cat 2001 in case
$14.00
View Details
Ty Beanie Babies Mattie 2001/2002 RARE WITH ERRORS
$157.50
View Details
Lot of 5 TY Beanie Babies ~ Ziggy, Mattie, Inch, Spot & Sneaky ~ Worm, Leopard
$24.80
View Details
Rare Beanie Baby Birthday Year Miss Printed On Tag Mattie Beanie Baby
$100.00
View Details
TY Beanie Baby - MATTIE the Cat (7 inch) - Date of birth April 26, 2001
$499.00
View Details
ty beanie baby mattie/ MINT TAGS, in immaculate condition!
$39.00
View Details
Original Ty Beanie Baby 22 Yrs!😻MATTIE Ginger Tabby Cat😻2001/02 10/11 Gen NWMT
$18.00
View Details
TY Beanie Babies Nuts & Stretch & Mattie Plush Stuffed Animal
$10.40
View Details
Ty Beanie Mattie the Cat No red stamp inside tush tag mismatched year MINT
$42.00
View Details
Ty Beanie Baby - MATTIE the Orange Tabby Cat (7 Inch) New with Tag
$19.99
View Details
Beanie Babies Cat Bundle, Siam the Siamese, Velvet the Panther, Prance, Mattie
$20.00
View Details
Ty Beanie Babies Mattie - (Cat 2001) flawless
$59.75
View Details
Ty Beanie Cats Fancy Carnation Fleur Amber Beani Frisco Pluff Kooky Mattie MWMT
$85.75
View Details
TY Beanie Babies Mattie The Cat 2001 MWNT Mint condition
$12.86
View Details
